Skip to Main Content
Back to News

Starbucks (SBUX) Faces Fourth Quarterly Sales Decline Amid Turnaround Efforts

Quiver Editor

Starbucks (SBUX) is expected to report a fourth consecutive quarterly decline in comparable store sales on Tuesday, as new CEO Brian Niccol continues to roll out measures aimed at reversing the coffee chain’s fortunes. Niccol, who joined Starbucks four months ago, has outlined initiatives such as reducing wait times, implementing a “coffeehouse code of conduct,” and restructuring management to improve store-level operations. Despite these efforts, analysts estimate a 4.6% drop in first-quarter comparable store sales and a 26% decline in profits, according to LSEG data.

The coffee giant is facing headwinds from weakening demand in key markets like the U.S. and China, as well as increasing competition. Niccol has prioritized enhancing customer experience over short-term profitability, pausing price hikes and increasing store hours to meet a target wait time of under four minutes. While investors are optimistic about the long-term potential, with Starbucks shares rising 28% since Niccol’s appointment, near-term challenges remain significant as the company executes its turnaround strategy.

Market Overview:
  • Starbucks is set to post its fourth straight quarterly decline in comparable store sales, down an estimated 4.6%.
  • Profit is expected to slump 26%, driven by paused price hikes and operational restructuring costs.
  • Shares have risen 28% since CEO Brian Niccol's appointment, signaling investor optimism about the turnaround plan.
Key Points:
  • Niccol’s strategy includes reducing wait times, enhancing in-store experience, and restructuring management layers.
  • The company has suspended fiscal 2025 guidance as it focuses on long-term improvements.
  • Cost pressures, including soaring coffee prices, continue to weigh on margins.
Looking Ahead:
  • Analysts expect multiple quarters before Starbucks sees significant traffic recovery from Niccol’s initiatives.
  • Pause on price hikes could support customer loyalty but may delay margin recovery.
  • China's demand trends and U.S. consumer behavior will be key drivers in Starbucks’ recovery trajectory.
Bull Case:
  • CEO Brian Niccol’s “Back to Starbucks” plan, focusing on reducing wait times, simplifying operations, and enhancing the in-store experience, has the potential to rebuild customer loyalty and drive long-term growth.
  • Starbucks’ decision to pause price hikes demonstrates a commitment to prioritizing customer satisfaction, which could strengthen brand loyalty and attract more traffic over time.
  • The company’s 28% share price increase since Niccol’s appointment reflects investor confidence in his turnaround strategy and its potential to deliver sustainable growth.
  • Niccol’s focus on returning Starbucks to its coffeehouse roots, including comfortable seating and personalized service, aligns with consumer preferences for experiential dining, potentially boosting foot traffic.
  • Operational improvements, such as restructuring management layers and addressing mobile order inefficiencies, could enhance store-level productivity and profitability in the long term.
Bear Case:
  • Starbucks is expected to report a fourth consecutive quarterly decline in comparable store sales (down 4.6%) and a 26% drop in profits, reflecting significant near-term challenges despite Niccol’s efforts.
  • High input costs, including soaring coffee prices, continue to pressure margins, while the pause on price hikes delays margin recovery and profitability improvements.
  • The company faces headwinds from weakening demand in key markets like the U.S. and China, where competition from other coffee chains and economic uncertainty remain significant obstacles.
  • Starbucks’ decision to suspend fiscal 2025 guidance creates uncertainty for investors about the timeline for recovery and the effectiveness of Niccol’s initiatives.
  • Near-term operational disruptions from restructuring efforts may outweigh the benefits of Niccol’s strategy, delaying meaningful improvements in traffic and sales metrics.

Despite the anticipated sales and profit declines, analysts remain cautiously optimistic about Starbucks’ turnaround under Niccol’s leadership. Measures to enhance customer experience, such as faster service and operational improvements, could help restore traffic over time. Stifel analyst Chris O’Cull believes the company can see improvements within a few quarters, though the timeline remains uncertain.

The company’s decision to pause price hikes, even amid rising input costs, underscores its focus on rebuilding customer loyalty. While short-term margins may suffer, the strategy aims to create a stronger foundation for sustainable growth. With shares rebounding 28% since Niccol’s appointment, the market is signaling confidence in the long-term potential of Starbucks’ recovery plan.

About the Author

David Love is an editor at Quiver Quantitative, with a focus on global markets and breaking news. Prior to joining Quiver, David was the CEO of Winter Haven Capital.

Add Quiver Quantitative to your Google News feed.Google News Logo

Suggested Articles