Skip to Main Content
Back to News

Big Oil's Record Returns in 2023: Balancing Profit and Sustainability

Quiver Quantitative Logo

The oil industry, commonly known as 'Big Oil', saw a pivotal year in 2023. Despite a significant drop in profits from the peak of 2022, major oil and gas companies like BP (BP), Chevron (CVX), Exxon Mobil (XOM), Shell (SHEL), and TotalEnergies (TTE) collectively returned over $111 billion to shareholders through dividends and buybacks. This figure marginally exceeded 2022's returns and was delivered amid a backdrop of global geopolitical instability and economic uncertainty. The sector's strategy was marked by a clear divide between American and European companies, with the former focusing on boosting oil production and the latter allocating more capital to low-carbon and renewable ventures.

Investor interest in oil majors, once a staple for steady, long-term dividends, has waned in recent years due to factors like the rise of the tech sector, oil price volatility, and growing environmental concerns. This shift is reflected in the energy sector's reduced weighting in the S&P 500 index, now at 4.4% compared to around 14% a decade ago. Despite this, the major oil firms have remained focused on maintaining investor confidence by ensuring predictable returns and demonstrating financial discipline.

Market Overview:
-Big Oil companies offer record $111 billion in dividends and buybacks in 2023.
-Despite profit decline, focus shifts to consistent returns and shareholder appeasement.
-Transatlantic strategy divide emerges, with some prioritizing green investments.

Key Points:
-BP, Chevron, Exxon Mobil, Shell, and TotalEnergies promise stability and higher payouts.
-Sector grapples with declining investor interest and uncertain energy demand outlook.
-Focus on capital discipline and emissions reduction as key to regaining trust.

Looking Ahead:
-Big Oil's ability to sustain high returns while navigating energy transition remains crucial.
-Investor sentiment and energy demand trends will determine sector's long-term prospects.
-Increased transparency and sustainability efforts could rebuild investor confidence.

The shared message to investors has been clear and consistent: loyalty to these companies will be rewarded with steady returns. This approach is highlighted by dividend increases from Shell, Chevron, and TotalEnergies, as well as BP's accelerated buyback rate. Exxon Mobil led the sector in shareholder returns, distributing $32 billion in 2023. The industry's commitment to investment discipline is driven not only by investor demand but also by the uncertain future of energy demand and the need to meet stricter return, emission, and regulatory benchmarks.

Looking ahead to 2024, minimal increases in spending are anticipated, reflecting the sector's focus on maintaining strong credit quality and balance sheet strength. This strategy is crucial for navigating the complex energy landscape, marked by shifting market dynamics and regulatory pressures. The concerted effort to balance shareholder returns with sustainable growth and environmental responsibility will likely define the sector's trajectory in the coming years.

About the Author

David Love is an editor at Quiver Quantitative, with a focus on global markets and breaking news. Prior to joining Quiver, David was the CEO of Winter Haven Capital.

Suggested Articles